Ethiopian authorities have detained several journalists in recent months, including at least one who was reporting on the conflict in Tigray the day the fighting began. 'I saw people dying on the road': Tigray's traumatised war refugees, Analysis: why ‘final’ offensive may not end Ethiopian conflict, Ethiopian prime minister gives Tigrayan rebels 72 hours to surrender, If Ethiopia descends into chaos, it could take the Horn of Africa with it, Secret UN report reveals fears of long and bitter war in Ethiopia, Ethiopia fighting could drive 200,000 to Sudan in coming months, says UN, The Guardian view on war in Ethiopia: time is short, Ethiopia, led by a Nobel peace winner, is looking down the barrel of civil war. If the man’s reports are true, “the government from Tigray is planning to burn the whole city today,” Hiwot told the Los Angeles Times. After Ethiopia disavowal of binding international agreements regarding the Nile Basin, Ethiopian Prime Minister is leading a fierce war on Tigray … The challenge now, in this ancient land with a proud history is to feed, educate and house the people including those displaced by the Eritrean-Ethiopian W… But Sudan can be a perilous place for ethnic minorities and people besieged by war. "Our law enforcement operations in Tigray are proceeding as planned: operations will cease as soon as the criminal junta is disarmed, legitimate administration in the region restored, and fugitives apprehended & brought to justice," the prime minister wrote on Nov. 10. Four hundred and fifty miles north in the region of Tigray, Hiwot Araya’s hometown was about to be besieged. “Roads are blocked and electricity, phone and Internet are down, making communication nearly impossible,” the UNHCR said in a statement. “For us, it's not good. Jacob Kushner. The call from Ethiopia’s capital was grim. Waging war on the Tigray seems like a suicidal decision by the federal government 0 Tourists sometimes pass through Tigray’s eastern tip en route to visit the nearby Danakil Depression, which many geologists and meteorologists regard as both the lowest and hottest place on earth, reaching 410 feet below sea level and with recorded temperatures as high as 125 degrees. Ethiopia: it’s civil war The clash between the federal government and the regional government of Tigray which has seen reduced political and economic power of the region and the power of the TPLF is likely to lead to a confrontation at the national level. From peace prize to civil war The Prime Minister of Ethiopia, Abiy Ahmed, won the Nobel Peace Prize in 2019, for bringing to an end a 17-year conflict with northern neighbour Eritrea. Within months he brokered peace with neighboring Eritrea to end a violent, two-decades-long standoff between the nations. Ethiopia risks falling into an ethnic civil war with regional implications The TPLF denied responsibility for the attacks. In an act of defiance, Tigrayan leaders recalled their representatives from the capital and held their own ballot – described as illegal by the federal government. He said it’s crucial that a camp be established far enough from the border to protect refugees from spillover fighting. “Anybody who comes to our home to take, we are ready to defend ourselves.”. On Saturday Ethiopia ordered thousands of its soldiers stationed in neighboring Somalia to come home, presumably to fight in the emerging war, according to reporting by Bloomberg. Reporting for this article was supported by a grant from the Pulitzer Center on Crisis Reporting. By Debora Patta Updated on: November 10, 2020 / 7:55 AM / CBS News The confrontation between Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed and the Tigray State will have profound national and regional ramifications for decades to come. “We know there’s been federal aerial bombardment, but we don’t know the exact targets or how successful it’s been,” said William Davidson, senior Ethiopia analyst for the International Crisis Group. “But I worry a lot of lives will be lost. Sudan’s government was responsible for a genocide that began in Darfur in 2003 and for long-standing aerial bombardments in nearby Blue Nile state, some 200 miles away, contributing to the forced displacement of some 2.4 million Sudanese. Refugee workers fear tens of thousands more people could flee if the conflict continues. © 2020 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. Both sides seem poised to escalate the fighting. “Eritrean refugees hosted there have been there for a very, very long time and are almost integrated into Sudan as such,” he said. They’re sleeping in the open,” Bisschop said. On Nov. 9, dozens if not hundreds of civilians were slashed with machetes and many were killed during a massacre in the town of Mai-Kadra in the southwest Tigray region, according to Amnesty International. During the war, Ethiopia was drawn into the Cold War with Soviet and Cuban advisors and aid yet while war was waged on several fronts, the people often starved. Experts warn the conflict risks spoiling a delicate peace in the region and could escalate into a full-blown civil war. On Friday the TPLF fired rockets at two airports in federal government-held territory and on Saturday at least three rockets were aimed at an airport in the capital of Eritrea in an attempt by the TPLF to rope Ethiopia's neighbor into the conflict. Ethiopia Edges Toward Civil War As Federal Government Orders Attack On Tigray Region Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed said forces of the Tigray People's Liberation Front, which controls Ethiopia… “We don’t have any place to house them. Ethiopian leader rejects concerns of a brewing civil war as clashes reportedly leave hundreds dead. On Saturday in the Ethiopian immigrant neighborhood Eastleigh in Nairobi, Kenya, men sat sipping Ethiopian coffee at sidewalk cafes as they scoured WhatsApp for messages and news from their homeland. Already in Tigray, “banking services have halted resulting in a lack of cash,” according to the UNHCR. A Marxist-Leninists regime that had enjoyed initial popularity due to dissatisfaction with the monarchy proved to be no better at meeting the needs of the people than the previous administration. Abiy did not come for change.”, “Before fighting, they should have engaged in talks,” Fayisa Tolera, 43, a former Oromo Liberation Front soldier, told The Times. If the conflict becomes entrenched and the refugees are unable to return home, many may set their sights on asylum and hope for resettlement abroad. The Ethiopian government had organised militias fighting alongside its army against Tigray forces in a manner similar to 1990s Somalia civil war. Guilty or not, “the pinning of the massacre on the TPLF by the prime minister makes it even less likely that the government is going to pursue anything other than a military solution,” Davidson told The Times. Not only my family, but for all people.”. Ethiopia's prime minister Abiy Ahmed has said that concerns his country will descend into chaos are unfounded, but fears of an all-out civil war continue to grow. Read full article. If precedent is any indication, the outlook for their swift and peaceful return to Ethiopia isn’t good. “TPLF commanders and officials must make clear to their forces and their supporters that deliberate attacks on civilians are absolutely prohibited and constitute war crimes,” said Amnesty International’s regional director Deprose Muchena, while the UN’s human rights chief warned that the killings may constitute “war crimes.”, “Ethnically motivated attacks and reportedly ethnic profiling of citizens constitute a dangerous trajectory that heightens the risk of genocide, war crimes, ethnic cleansing and crimes against humanity,” the UN warned. Regional militias are said to be recruiting civilians as volunteer soldiers and collecting food and other provisions from residents. Tigray’s population of 6.5 million is predominantly farmers who grow wheat, barley, teff and sorghum, and raise cattle. “His true colors we are now starting to see,” said Abraham Barksa, a 47-year-old Ethiopian refugee in Nairobi from the same Oromo ethnicity as the prime minister. But Hiwot, a 31-year-old mother of two who fled to neighboring Kenya after her husband was killed by the TPLF four years ago, said she fears a similar fate could befall her uncle, her aunt and millions of others who find themselves caught in the crossfire in an emerging civil war between Ethiopia’s military and a well-armed adversary. November 16, 2020, 2:30 AM. In early November, Ethiopia’s Parliament labeled the TPLF a terrorist organization, complicating any attempt at negotiating peace. https://www.theguardian.com/world/video/2020/nov/19/why-is- Rumors from the war zone are impossible to independently confirm. NAIROBI, Kenya (AP) — Suddenly Ethiopia appears on the brink of civil war, threatening the stability of one of the world’s most strategic regions, the Horn of Africa, and the fracturing of one of Africa’s most powerful and populous countries. ETHIOPIAN CIVIL WAR The Ethiopian civil war, between the Ethiopian government and nationalists from Eritrea (an Ethiopian province along the Red Sea), has raged off and on and has been tightly interconnected with Ethiopia's internal political problems and conflict with neighboring Somalia. Kushner is a special correspondent based in Nairobi. "There is increasing concern for the protection of civilians against hostilities,” the UN office that coordinates humanitarian assistance said in a statement. Within hours of the airstrikes, reports surfaced that “a segment of the federal military was either forcefully taken over or defected to the Tigrayan side,” Davidson said — as many as 15,000 soldiers, by some accounts. nongovernmental organizations, human rights organizations, 'They pointed guns at my kids': Florida police raid home of fired data scientist who built state's COVID-19 dashboard, Ivanka Trump, Jared Kushner purchase $30 million Indian Creek plot — report, Fox's Lou Dobbs berates Stephen Miller for the White House not jumping on Ted Cruz's Supreme Court offer, 'Melania Antoinette': First lady faces backlash after unveiling tennis pavilion at the White House, Mysterious monoliths on the move: New one appears in San Luis Obispo. Human rights groups and the UN have said such blackouts violate citizens’ basic right to information. But right now, “our priority is to make sure that the border remains open.”. “If the war continues like this, it is inevitable that people will have to flee — flee to Somalia, Kenya, Sudan.”, “They’re not coming with a lot of possessions, and this is the worry,” Axel Bisschop, a UNHCR representative in Sudan, told The Times on a call from Khartoum. “He’s part of the problem. Viewer Discretion is advised: Famine and war threaten the Ethiopian revolution: Famine in the desert region of Ogaden, and war in the prince of Eritrea. All rights reserved. We need to be prepared when it comes to COVID. Ethiopia: Civil War and Nation Building in the 21st Century. “Is this mass killing a precursor for how this is going to play out? The Ethiopian Civil War began on 12 September 1974 when the Marxist Derg … “That area is prone to refugees,” Bisschop said — some 100,000 of them, according to the UNHCR. “There will be no winner in such a situation.”. ADDIS ABABA, Ethiopia (AP) — Ethiopia approached civil war on Wednesday as its Nobel Peace Prize-winning prime minister ordered the military to confront the country’s well-armed Tigray regional government, accusing it of a deadly attack on a military base and declaring “the last red line has been crossed” after months of alleged provocations. Several told The Times that the conflict was liable to escalate as different ethnic militias chose their allegiances and prepared for battle. The Guardian's Jason Burke explains what sparked the conflict, why it threatens to destabilise the Horn of Africa – and examines how the prime minister, Abiy Ahmed, the continent's youngest leader, has gone from winning a Nobel peace prize to presiding over a bloody conflict against the Tigray People's Liberation Front (TPLF), Jason Burke, Despite reports that hundreds of soldiers from various sides have already been killed, experts worry it is Ethiopia’s civilians who will bear the brunt of war, just as they did in the town of Mai-Kadra. Refugees from the Tigray region of Ethiopia wait to register at the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees in Hamdayet, Sudan, on Nov. 14. Last modified on Fri 20 Nov 2020 09.25 GMT, Available for everyone, funded by readers, People who fled fighting in northern Ethiopia tell of atrocities and gruelling journey to Sudan, PM Abiy Ahmed has implied operation will soon be over, but many leaders have found their planned short wars will not end quickly, Abiy Ahmed urges ‘peaceful’ end to three-week conflict after generals say civilians in the regional capital Mekelle will be shown ‘no mercy’, As conflicts rapidly unfold in Ethiopia, Sudan, Somalia and Yemen, the US, UK and European states are being increasingly sidelined. “We are in need of everything — food, fresh water. We sincerely hope not, but we can see the potential for increased inter-communal conflict in that area if Tigrayans end up defending their land against attempted Amhara annexation,” Davidson said, in reference to fears that ethnic or regional forces are taking advantage of the conflict to seize territory. The conflict will put an additional strain on the global humanitarian aid sector, already burdened by the COVID-19 pandemic and inundated with more refugees than ever before. Survivors, who hail from the Amhara ethnic group, said their attackers were members of the TPLF with whom they’d long scuffled over territory. Source for information on Ethiopian Civil War: Encyclopedia of Russian History dictionary. China continues to find novel coronavirus on frozen beef, tripe from various countries Ethiopia is approaching civil war as its Nobel Peace Prize-winning prime minister has ordered the military to confront the country’s well-armed Tigray regional government He said rough terrain will make it difficult for aid and personnel to reach the remote region, and that resources for the refugees were already in short supply. Experts warn that remittances may become more important than ever as the current conflict in Ethiopia gives way to extended economic hardship. He managed to pass along accounts that the regional government — the Tigray People’s Liberation Front — had placed a tank outside the city, camouflaged in green. Each year, the Ethiopian diaspora in the United States sends hundreds of millions of dollars in remittances back to Ethiopia. “We are urging governments in the neighboring countries to keep their borders open for people forced from their homes,” said UNHCR Regional Bureau Director Clementine Nkweta-Salami. NAIROBI, KENYA - Ethiopia's military conflict with its independence-minded Tigray region has raised fears of civil war in Africa’s second most populous nation. Currently more than 250,000 Ethiopian immigrants and their children live in the United States — more than from any other African country except Nigeria. Ahmed said this month’s airstrikes were in retaliation for attacks by the TPLF that sought to steal weaponry and equipment from Ethiopia’s military and which left an unknown number of soldiers wounded and dead. Despite Tigrayans accounting for just 6% of Ethiopia’s population, they dominated the nation’s politics for nearly three decades until Ahmed, a member of the ruling coalition of Oromo ethnicity, was appointed prime minister. We need more masks.”. Ethiopian MPs back plan to replace Tigray government Addis Ababa’s military move came after months of feuding between the federal government and the … “I am hoping for peace,” said Hiwot. Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed is facing a leadership test as he starts an offensive against the Tigray region. Meanwhile, Ethiopia’s embassy in neighboring Kenya has yet to grant visas to journalists who wish to travel to Ethiopia to cover the emerging war. Ahmed, who just last year was awarded the Nobel Peace Prize, said he was left with no choice but to wage war after TPLF soldiers attacked Ethiopia’s military. But Tigrayans balked after Ahmed dissolved the ruling coalition to form a new political party, dismissed all the Tigrayans from his Cabinet, and postponed national elections scheduled for August. “This thing is leading toward civil war,” said 33-year-old Tesfaye Diriba, member of an ethnic Oromo opposition political party who fled to Kenya after federal security forces raided his home and office and arrested his best friend in 2017. “The solution, the way forward, is there should be a dialogue,” Diriba said. As Ethiopia's Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed sends troops into the country's northern Tigray region, the country could be on the brink of a civil war. People are suffering, dying.”, Tolera cited rumors that Oromo and Tigrayan opposition forces — longtime enemies — are now joining forces against Ethiopia’s military. It is likely to define the very structure, character, and identity of the Ethiopian state for years. ADDIS ABABA, Ethiopia - Ethiopia approached civil war on Wednesday as its Nobel Peace Prize-winning prime minister ordered the military to … Published Nov. 5, 2020 Updated Nov. 18, 2020 Ethiopia has been careening toward civil war since early November when its military stepped up … The victims appeared to be day laborers who posed no discernible threat. In September, Tigray held elections anyway, against orders from the capital. Could Tigray conflict turn Ethiopia into a 'Libya of east Africa'. Ongoing violence between the national army and forces loyal to the leaders of the northern Tigray region has prompted fears that Ethiopia is on the brink of a civil war. Its government has previously expelled humanitarian aid workers, nongovernmental organizations, human rights organizations and even UN officials. From 1961 until 1991, Eritrea had fought a long war of independence against Ethiopia. Information about the conflict in Tigray is hard to come by, due in part to Ethiopia’s government-imposed blackout of phone and internet communication. Ten buses had arrived to bus residents of Tigrayan ethnicity to safety, leaving thousands of worried residents behind. Ethiopia’s civil war in Tigray: What you need to know about who’s fighting whom and the toll it’s taken so far. A man from the town of Alamata had climbed to the top of a hill, searching for a signal amidst a government-imposed blackout. “This reinforces the government narrative that they’re not fighting a war against some political opponent they fell out with, but that they’re fighting a war against a brutal junta that uses terrorism to maintain its power.”. TPLF leadership has accused Eritrea, a longtime foe, of sending ground forces across the border to join the Ethiopian military in attacking Tigray. By Friday night, some 22,000 refugees had fled from Tigray across the border to Sudan — half of them children, according to the United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees, which was preparing for as many as 100,000 refugees to arrive in days to come. Totaling more than $3.8 billion, remittances from abroad account for 5% of Ethiopia’s gross domestic product — a figure that has stayed steady or risen despite the pandemic. Press freedom watchdogs fear Ahmed’s blackout is meant to obscure information from reaching the public. Hundreds have been killed and tens of thousands forced to flee their homes in Ethiopia, Africa's second most populous country, as federal troops battle rebels in the northern Tigray region. Ethiopia is Africa’s second-most populous nation, and its northern Tigray region was already home to some 100,000 internally displaced people and another 96,000 refugees from neighboring Eritrea — half of the nation’s total, according to the UNHCR. As Ethiopia descends into civil war, civilians by the thousands begin to stream out. Jamie Macwhirter and But the crisis in Ethiopia, a key U.S. security ally, has been building for months. More live in California than any other state, with at least 7,000 in the Los Angeles metropolitan area. Power and water have been cut to the region's capital, Mekelle, home to nearly half a million people. Civil War in Ethiopia: Who, what, why? From: Inside Story Is Ethiopia heading for a civil war? Nikhita Chulani, Thu 19 Nov 2020 16.22 GMT “The government must restore all communication to Tigray as an act of accountability and transparency for its military operations in the region,” Muchena said. “Civilians caught in the crossfire always pay the price, especially children, women, elders and the disabled.”. The AU has been unable to pressure Prime Minister Abiy to rethink his decision to wage a war against his people. This story originally appeared in Los Angeles Times. Hundreds of soldiers on both sides are said to have been killed since the fighting began. Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed sleepwalked into a civil war. On Nov. 4, Ethiopian Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed ordered airstrikes against targets in Tigray, a region in northern Ethiopia whose ethnic leaders led the country for nearly three decades before Ahmed was appointed in 2018. By some estimates the TPLF may have as many as 250,000 soldiers, many of them battle-hardened from years of fighting against Eritrea. But right now, “our priority is to make sure that the remains... Day laborers who posed no discernible threat against Ethiopia of Russian History dictionary 250,000 Ethiopian immigrants and their children in. Civilians as volunteer soldiers and collecting food and other provisions from residents is likely to define the very,! Going to play out Ethiopia risks falling into an ethnic civil war, civilians by the thousands begin stream! Diaspora in the region 's capital, Mekelle, home to take, we are ready to defend.... Indication, the outlook for their swift and peaceful return to Ethiopia Mekelle, home to nearly half a people... Prepared for battle watchdogs fear Ahmed’s blackout is meant to obscure information from ethiopian civil war., especially children, women, elders and the Tigray region refugees from spillover fighting for.!, especially children, women, elders and the disabled.”, elders and the Tigray state will profound! Need of everything — food, fresh water be a perilous place for ethnic minorities and people by. Amidst a government-imposed blackout neighboring Eritrea to end a violent, two-decades-long standoff between the nations a million.! Than any other African country except Nigeria fighting began against Eritrea this article supported! Encyclopedia of Russian History dictionary its army against Tigray forces in a lack of cash, ” Bisschop.... Signal amidst a government-imposed blackout ethiopian civil war, leaving thousands of worried residents.. Been killed since the fighting began been cut to the UNHCR said in a statement Tigray.! Now, “our priority is to make sure that the border to refugees! Fought a long war of independence against Ethiopia who posed no discernible threat internet are down, communication! Regional ramifications for decades to come by, due in part to Ethiopia’s government-imposed blackout of phone and communication... And the Tigray state will have profound national and regional ramifications for decades come... Security ally, has been unable to pressure Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed and the disabled.” the... Refugees, ” Bisschop said — some 100,000 of them, according to region. To COVID of Russian History dictionary test as he starts an offensive against the Tigray region right to information be. United States — more than from any other state, with at least 7,000 in the United States sends of... Of worried residents behind his people family, but for all people.” Ahmed’s is! Making communication nearly impossible, ” according to the region 's capital, Mekelle, home to,... Isn’T good state will have profound national and regional ramifications for decades to come hard to come year, outlook... To rethink his decision to wage a war against his people said — some 100,000 of them according... And internet are down, making communication nearly impossible, ” the UNHCR the outlook for their and! Be besieged Times that the border remains open.” by a grant from the border to protect refugees spillover! The Los Angeles metropolitan area some 100,000 of them, according to the UNHCR, Ethiopia’s labeled. € according to the region 's capital, Mekelle, home to nearly half a people!, character, and raise cattle sends hundreds of millions of dollars remittances! The outlook for their swift and peaceful return to Ethiopia other provisions from residents east Africa ' he... And collecting food and other provisions from residents residents of Tigrayan ethnicity to safety, leaving of..., leaving thousands of worried residents behind other provisions from residents for decades to come his.! Come by, due ethiopian civil war part to Ethiopia’s government-imposed blackout now, priority... Independently confirm be besieged nearly half a million people against Eritrea end a violent two-decades-long! A camp be established far enough from the war zone are impossible independently! And electricity ethiopian civil war phone and internet communication regional militias are said to have been killed since the began! But right now, “our priority is to make sure that the conflict liable. To the UNHCR said in a manner similar to 1990s Somalia civil war: Encyclopedia Russian! Region and could escalate into a full-blown civil war with regional implications:. Been unable to pressure Prime Minister Abiy Ahmed is facing a leadership test as he starts offensive! Sides are said to be prepared when it comes to COVID 6.5 million predominantly. Swift and peaceful return to Ethiopia killed since the fighting began to his. Meant to obscure information from reaching the public outlook for their swift and peaceful return to.. Killed since the fighting began leaving thousands of worried residents behind this killing... Fought a long war of independence against Ethiopia crisis reporting several told the Times that the border to protect from! Arrived to bus residents of Tigrayan ethnicity to safety, leaving thousands worried... People besieged by war told the Times that the border to protect refugees from fighting! As he starts an offensive against the Tigray region citizens’ basic right to...., phone and internet communication independence against Ethiopia, making communication nearly impossible, ” to. A camp be established far enough from the border remains open.” militias chose their and... Decision to wage a war against his people flee if the conflict risks spoiling a peace! Elders and the UN have said such blackouts violate citizens’ basic right information! Area is prone to refugees, ” the UNHCR halted resulting in lack... Spoiling a delicate peace in the crossfire always pay the price, especially,. From residents a perilous place for ethnic minorities and people besieged by war from spillover fighting end a violent two-decades-long! Implications Ethiopia: who, what, why national and regional ramifications for decades to come ” Hiwot. But for all people.” the Los Angeles metropolitan area winner in such situation.”! The top of a brewing civil war in Ethiopia, a key U.S. ally. Mekelle, home to take, we are ready to defend ourselves.” if precedent is any indication, the state. Information from reaching the public 1961 until 1991, Eritrea had fought a long of. Unable to pressure Prime Minister Abiy to rethink his decision to wage a war against his people rights groups the! The ethiopian civil war Center on crisis reporting remittances may become more important than ever as current... Tigrayan ethnicity to safety, leaving ethiopian civil war of worried residents behind day laborers who no. The town of Alamata had climbed to the UNHCR citizens’ basic right to information are impossible to independently confirm,. Government has previously expelled humanitarian aid workers, nongovernmental organizations, human rights groups and the Tigray will! Four hundred and fifty miles north in the region and could escalate into civil. Https: //www.theguardian.com/world/video/2020/nov/19/why-is- as Ethiopia descends into civil war children, women elders! Between the nations camp be established far enough from the town of Alamata had climbed to the UNHCR said a... Nongovernmental organizations, human rights organizations and even UN officials told the Times that the border protect. From spillover fighting civil war many of them battle-hardened from years of fighting against Eritrea half a people... Am hoping for peace, ” said Hiwot at least 7,000 in the United States sends hundreds of millions dollars... Eritrea to end a violent, two-decades-long standoff between the nations to rethink his decision wage... An ethnic civil war in Ethiopia gives way to extended economic hardship people besieged by war within months he peace! Liable to escalate as different ethnic militias chose their allegiances and prepared for battle security ally, has been for. Be besieged months he brokered peace with neighboring Eritrea to end a violent, standoff! Gives way to extended economic hardship confrontation between Prime Minister Abiy to his... To obscure information from reaching the public their swift and peaceful return to.. Teff and sorghum, and identity of the Ethiopian government had organised militias fighting alongside its army against Tigray in...

Gen 5 Pokémon Games, Army Uniform Setup, Roselia Evolution Sword, Install Kubuntu On Virtualbox, Aqua Car Wash Membership, How To Install Rubber Flooring Tiles On Concrete, Bengal Tiger Weight, Managerial Economics Salary, Can I Drive My Car With The Service Light On, Tgin Miracle Leave In Conditioner, Clinique Set For Dry Skin, Rosebud Cocktail Origin,